Tip #50: "Indexed Keywords" in Scopus: what they are, where they come from, and how (and whether) to exclude them

By

Scopus is a very large multidisciplinary database with a wide range of sources. According to Elsevier, almost 99% of journals indexed in Embase and MEDLINE are included in Scopus. Unlike Embase, which uses the Emtree thesaurus for indexing (the full Emtree thesaurus is only available in Embase), or MEDLINE, which uses MeSH (accessible publicly via the MeSH Browser or MeSH Database), Scopus does not have its own controlled vocabulary or thesaurus searching capabilities. So what are the "indexed keywords" in Scopus? And are they beneficial or harmful to your searches?

The origins of "indexed keywords"

Journal article records in Scopus are supplied directly from publishers, and thus arrive with no indexing. Scopus then enriches these references whenever possible, using thesauri Elsevier either owns or licenses. The “indexed keywords” that display in references are added when Scopus finds an exact item match with a reference from Embase or MEDLINE. For example, an article indexed in Embase will be enriched with most (but not all) Emtree terms; an article indexed in MEDLINE will have most (but not all) MeSH terms applied. References indexed in both Embase and MEDLINE will have terms from both thesauri. Some common examples of missing indexing include Emtree device terms and MeSH subheadings, neither of which will be found in Scopus indexed keywords. 

How is the indexing different in Scopus, MEDLINE, and Embase?

PMID 38166804 is an illustrative example.

Full PubMed citation for PMID 38166804: Smartphone-based educational and counseling interventions for women with high body mass index at Urmia's health centers

PubMed lists the following MeSH terms, with slashes indicating subheadings and stars denoting "major topics": Body Mass Index; Counseling; Female; Humans; Iran; Obesity* / epidemiology; Obesity* / therapy; Pregnancy; Smartphone*

MeSH terms from PubMed

Scopus's MeSH for the same article are: Body Mass Index; Counseling; Female; Humans; Iran; Obesity; Pregnancy; Smartphone. What's different? Subheadings are not part of the Scopus record enrichment, nor are indicators of major topics.

MeSH terms from Scopus

The same article is also in Embase. The Embase record lists the following Emtree terms, with bold indicating "major focus": Device terms: mobile application; smartphone ; Other terms: adult; article; awareness; body mass; controlled study; counseling; data analysis; fast food; female; food intake; health care quality; health center; health education; human; major clinical study; prevalence; randomized controlled trial; sedentary lifestyle

Emtree terms from Embase

Scopus's Emtree terms are: adult; Article; awareness; body mass; controlled study; counseling; data analysis; fast food; female; food intake; health care quality; health center; health education; human; major clinical study; prevalence; randomized controlled trial; sedentary lifestyle; body mass; counseling; Iran; obesity; pregnancy. What's different? Device terms are not part of the Scopus record enrichment, nor are indicators of major focus.

Emtree terms from Scopus

Do you want to search indexed keywords?

Since institutions who don't have MEDLINE access on a subscription interface can still use PubMed, whether or not to search indexed keywords is more likely to be determined based on Embase access. 

For those without access to Embase, it may be beneficial to include indexed keywords in your search. While you cannot search the Emtree thesaurus directly, indexed keywords do allow you to take some advantage of the Emtree indexing. Unfortunately, it's not possible to exclude indexed keywords by thesaurus (e.g., to include Emtree terms, imperfect as they are, but exclude MeSH).

For those with access to Embase, it makes sense to exclude indexed keywords. You'll already be able to take full advantage of the Emtree thesaurus and perform searches with appropriate vocabulary and syntax directly in Embase. In addition, inconsistent or incomplete index terms originating from the enriching process may introduce a lot of unnecessary noise when searching a database the size of Scopus.

How do you include or exclude indexed keywords?

Scopus offers three different field codes (see the Scopus Support Hub for a full list of available field codes) for searching keywords:

  • AUTHKEY searches keywords assigned by authors, which are part of the original publisher records.
  • INDEXTERMS searches controlled vocabulary terms added to Scopus during the enrichment process described above. Searches of INDEXTERMS also “take into account synonyms, various spellings, and plurals.” As with other searches in Scopus, using “quotation marks” does a loose phrase search; to work around whatever automated actions Scopus normally takes with INDEXTERMS searches, use {curly brackets} around exact phrases, bearing in mind that truncation cannot be used within curly brackets.
  • KEY is a composite field that searches the fields AUTHKEY, INDEXTERMS, TRADENAME, and CHEMNAME. The default search in Scopus, TITLE-ABS-KEY, includes this field code.

To include indexed keywords, simply use the default KEY field, either on its own or in a TITLE-ABS-KEY search.

To exclude indexed keywords, use the AUTHKEY field rather than KEY. There is no combined field search of this type, so researchers can use the Advanced Document Search option to search TITLE-ABS() OR AUTHKEY() to replace TITLE-ABS-KEY()

The Scopus search history below shows the significant differences in search results when including or excluding indexed keywords. For accessibility and ease of replicating the search, the full history is provided in both text and image.

Search History

Line number Search string Number of results
5 TITLE-ABS-KEY ( ( smartphone* OR "mobile application*" ) AND "body mass" ) 1430
4 ( TITLE-ABS ( smartphone* OR "mobile application*" ) OR AUTHKEY ( smartphone* OR "mobile application*" ) ) AND ( TITLE-ABS ( "body mass" ) OR AUTHKEY ( "body mass" ) ) 598
3 KEY ( ( smartphone* OR "mobile application*" ) AND "body mass" ) 856
2 INDEXTERMS ( ( smartphone* OR "mobile application*" ) AND "body mass" ) 753
1 AUTHKEY ( ( smartphone* OR "mobile application*" ) AND "body mass" ) 15

Scopus search history showing differences in numbers among various search field constructions

For additional information on Scopus content and how indexing appears in its records, consult the current Scopus Content Coverage Guide.

Many thanks to Zahra Premji, University of Victoria Libraries, and Krizia Tuand, Learning Centre Désiré Collen, KU Leuven Libraries – 2Bergen, Belgium and co-secretary of the EAHIL special interest group for evidence-based information, for their insights on this topic.

Comments

  1. Michele McGinnisJune 26, 2024 at 5:34 PM

    Hilary, this is another great post. I just discovered this NOT-based CADTH search filter for SCOPUS that removes citations derived from the MEDLINE/PubMed and Embase databases. https://searchfilters.cadth.ca/link/97

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Tip #1: Bulk export from Google Scholar

By
Image
This post was updated on October 10, 2022 with new instructions for #3 under "For EndNote users..." For years, I kept hearing from colleagues that I should be searching Google Scholar as part of my systematic review projects. I didn't, for 3 reasons: I didn't know GS' search syntax GS notoriously does not allow bulk export to reference managers I didn't have a sense of how many results I should export.   Last fall, I finally said enough was enough and it was time to learn how to wrangle this beast. It turns out that there is now a third-party tool that facilitates bulk export from Google Scholar, Harzing's Publish or Perish . Here's how you get started: Download PoP for free Paste your query into the Keywords field Set your maximum number of results. I follow the guidelines on p. 135 of Wichor Bramer's dissertation , which is a great handbook for expert searching. Bramer suggests the first 200 results, or 100 if you are getting low numbers of res
Read more

Tip #46: Exporting Records from Clinicaltrials.gov into EndNote

By
Image
Many thanks to Ben Harnke, MLIS from the Strauss Health Sciences Library, University of Colorado (ben.harnke@cuanschutz.edu) for this week's tip!   Overview The following are instructions to export records from clincicaltrials.gov (Trials) to EndNote, with the ultimate goal of sending the records to a screening software, namely Covidence. The new Trials website ( https://www.clinicaltrials.gov /) will only export in JSON (Java Script format) and Comma Separated Values (CSV) formats. We will be using the CSV export format, the format for spreadsheets. These instructions are simply slight modifications to the Clarivate instructions for importing tab-delimited files (spreadsheets) into EndNote. Before proceeding with the following instructions, first decide whether it is necessary to export directly from clinicaltrials.gov to begin with. Cochrane CENTRAL contains records from Trials and is more user friendly. CENTRAL is limited to "randomized and quasi-randomized controlled tri
Read more

Tip #23: PubMed's [tiab] vs. [tw]

By
Image
Search field tags are a quick way to specify the exact fields you would like to search when using keywords. For example, I can tell PubMed to search for my term only in the title field or only in the MeSH Terms field. You can view a list of available search fields from the drop down menu in PubMed's Advanced Search Builder. Specifying field tags for keywords is also a good practice in PubMed because keywords searched without field tags will be translated through Automatic Term Mapping which may reduce the precision of your results. Here are a few sample searches in my search history, including #4 which wasn't limited to a field (notice how it was translated in the expanded search details): The fields that are included in the [title/abstract] fields are pretty self-explanatory (words and numbers included in a citation's title, collection title, abstract, other abstract and author keywords), but what is actually included in the [Text Word] (can also be searched as [tw]) fi
Read more